16th & 17th August 2008

75 matches, 1 Tournament, 28 Players, £000 Prize Fund,
Peter Bennet wins MSO Vincent Square Cup 2008.


MSO 2008 – The Vincent Square Cup
 

9.00am and there is a cluster of MSO players outside the Royal Horticultural Conference Centre. The good news as far as backgammon is concerned is that I know most of the faces which means most of the MSO players are backgammon players.

At 9.30am some players are still going through the registration desk so we didn’t kick off until 10.00am. Given the early hour of the day for backgammon players no problem there!

And we have 28 backgammoners! An enormous figure compared to recent years; a fact I put down to the venue being back in central London, it being advertised via Bg in London as well as Biba and the offer of a free seat to Bg Live in London November 2008 if there are 20 or more players present.

Round 1 saw a couple of pairings to raise an eyebrow: Peter Bennet versus Rachel Rhodes (11-8) and WSOB Doubles winners Lawrence Powell versus Nicky Check (11-7). Other winners in Round 1 were:
Irving Czechowicz, Andy Guthrie, Paul Gilberson, Mike Heard, , Alex Polden, Geoff Oliver, Vicki Ondis, Neil Foston, Graham Read, John Reddington, Ritchie Newbold and Graham Palour.

Despite being listed here as the last name Graham Palour was the first to register a win because he was drawn against Uldis Lapikens who had pre-paid his MSO entry fee but wasn’t with us at 10.00am. and was of course entitled to his seat until such time as he timed out a he did at 10.30am. Graham was happy enough!

Round 2: Having started R2 with 14 players on 1 win out of 1 played and reduced to 7 players on 2 out of 2. They were: Irving Czechowicz, Mike Heard, Peter Bennet, Geoff Oliver, Vicki Ondis, Graham Read and John Reddington.

Round 3: Surviving on 3 out of 3 are: Irving Czechowicz, Peter Bennet, Graham Read and Vicki Ondis

Round 4: Surviving on 4 out of 4 are: Irving Czechowicz and Peter Bennet.
 

Here’s a position from the Powell versus Rhodes match in Round 4:

Pip count: Black 103, White 156. Score 9-9 (to 11).
Cube action?
 

And here ended the play for this day. You could be forgiven for thinking that the next round will be the last round but this will not be so. For this is an event with Biba Grand Prix points up for grabs and must therefore by definition have 6 (not 5) matches played. Yes, I too find Swiss very complicated!

So Irv will play Peter which will leave one of them on 5 out of 5. But in Round 6 the winner of that match could go a fluff the gold medal when they play and the Silver and Bronze are also up for grabs by those currently on 3 out of 4 who could promote themselves to 5 out of 6 by the end. It’s all a lot more complex than Knockouts are!
 

MSO London 2008 Vincent Square Cup
*PAIRINGS FOR ROUND 5:
Peter Bennet v Irving Czechowicz
Graham Read v Vicki Ondis
John Reddington v Mike Heard
Alex Polden v Nicky Check
Geoff Oliver v Steve Rimmer
Cliff Connick v Michael Harris
Cynthia Roberts v Rachel Rhodes
Chris Purchase v Josef Kollar
Stewart Pemberton v Lawrence Powell
Andy Guthrie v Dale Taylor
Graham Parlour v Mick Vacarey
 

*5 Players informed me that they will not be there on Sunday. Also it must be presumed that Uldis Lapikens (who had paid registration fee but did not turn up - you lost that reg fee me thinks Uldis!) will also not be there tomorrow. So of the 28 original players we SHOULD be down to 22. If we are not these pairings might have to be re-considered. Yes, I hate Swiss!

So it’s 09.30am back down there tomorrow morning and watch this space more more news.

Sunday morning:
During the course of the previous evening the players have obviously sat down to work out the possible combinations of wins and losses and what it might all mean to them personally. So at 9.15am I’m hit with a barrage of questions all starting with “What if?” Every question is valid but I have tucked up my sleeve one simple answer: “If it gets as complicated as I think it all might them I’m going to send the data to the man who has vast experience in running this event, the man who is going to award Biba Grand Prix points and the man who understands Swiss a heck of a lot better than I – Michael Crane.” The players were more than happy with this reply and off they set to play.

2 players where a no show (insert Mike’s opinion of Swiss then delete it because it’s not publishable!) so Cliff Connick played Steve Rimmer which was actually fine because their results were as close as could be without re-matches having to happen. It was the top of the table match and the bottom of the table match that took the longest to play. This event has a 2 hours 15 minutes maximum play period per round. In the bottom of table match Mick V beat Graham Parlour in 2 hours 13 minutes and 30 seconds. In the top of the table match – the important match to decide placings – Peter Bennet beat Irving Czechowicz in 2 hours, 14 minutes and 15 seconds!

This left Peter on 5 out of 5 and 5 other players (Irving Czechowicz, Vicki Ondis, John Reddington, Nicky Check and Steve Rimmer) on 4 out of 5. Draw done top of the table pairings where thus:
 

Peter Bennet v John Reddington
Irving Czechowicz v Vicki Ondis
Nicky Check v Steve Rimmer
 

John beat Peter, Irving beat Vicki and Nicky beat Steve leaving me hating them all because this left me with 4 players (Peter, John, Irving and Nicky) on 5 out of 6! “It’s done this way,” “It’s done that way,” “No, but if you do that it doesn’t work because of this”, “Ah, but if you do that then this” are just four samples of sentences being said by players. I looked up from my desk, didn’t say a word and picked up my phone – Thank you Mr Tarrant, I’ll take your phone a friend option!

I explained the situation, Michael asked questions, I answered, no conclusion there so Michael asked more questions which I duly answered but now it was all getting into realms that were better seen on paper (actually computer) so the results files was sent via email to Michael for him to quietly decide the outcome of it all and if a play-off would be required.

Meanwhile there was another Bg event for me to run up in St John’s Wood at 2.45pm but fortunately all interested 4 players will be attending The Bg in London at Biba in early September so a play-off (in needed) could everybody realized happen there.

A little while later Michael called me back. A play-off was not needed. Placings were as follows:

Gold - Peter Bennet,
Silver - Irving Czechowicz
Bronze – John Reddington
 
Michael Crane: Positions 1, 2, 3 & 4 were decided using the criteria: Number of wins of opponents, then head-to-head for any ties resulting from number of wins of opponents.

Peter Bennet = 21 . . . beat Irving in head-to-head
Irving Czechowicz = 21 . . . lost to Peter in head-to-head
John Reddington = 18
Nicky Check = 16
 
Summary:
So from 28 our 3 winners were found. On the plus side a turnout of 28 players was excellent, the venue is superb, the Swiss format gives players a lot of play which is after all what they come for and Michael Crane’s experience and willingness to impart his considerable knowledge was invaluable. But, on the other side of the coin, I loath Swiss even more than I did! Bottom line – it’s good to see MSO in healthy shape.

There will be more MSO backgammon action over the following week...



 
Update on Monday 9th September:

Later on in the MSO week MSO overturned the Michael Crane / Mike Main decision and John Reddington was awarded a gold medal even though Mike Main had been given the gold, silver and bronze medals to be handed out at the Bg in London at Biba event in September 2008. Mike Main was not and still has not been officially informed of this decision though I have it on reliable information that a change has been made.

 I'm told that is was Tony Corfe of that overturned the decision.  However I do not see by what right Tony Corfe has a say in this matter this year.

From the MSO document: http://sweb.cz/hakvago/info.doc
The final decision on the interpretation of the rules of play and tie breaks in all events will be that of the Event Co-ordinator.

Further on in that document it goes on to list the roles of MSO personnel:
Tony Corfe (Event Manager)
Andrew Havery (Event Co-ordinator)

Therefore I consider the decision is Andrew Havery's not Tony Corfe's.
I fully understand that it was Tony Corfe's in previous years but I consider it is not his call according to the documentation of this years MSO.

If MSO are trying to commit hari-kari I must compliment them on their style.

A couple of weeks before the MSO event I wrote to Andrew Havery asking if there was to be an actual cup for the Tournament titled The Vincent Square Cup. I received no reply. However I asked him in person this question on the first day of the event to which he rather sheepishly replied that there was not. This I consider a rather shoddy and slightly deceitful way to run an event; how on earth can an event be titled "Whatever Cup" if there is no cup to play for? Bg in London therefore provided and paid for a trophy. 

Bg in London deplores with the manner in which the decision was made by MSO but has now awarded the medals in accordance to the MSO decision:
Gold - John Reddington,
Silver -
Peter Bennet,
Bronze –
Irving Czechowicz.

The trophy, donated by Bg in London and therefore I consider up to Bg in London to award to whom we choose, goes to the originally declared winner Peter Bennet.

Bg in London were due to give a free seat to the winner of the event at the forthcoming Bg Live in London November 2008. So should it go to John Reddington or Peter Bennet? Bg in London finds itself in a no win situation. Therefore it is our decision to award free entry to Bg Live in London Nov 2008 to both John Reddington and Peter Bennet. 



It is our sincere hope that this decision is acceptable to all the players and considering that all three players posed for photos shortly after this was announced we consider this to be so.

Bg in London deplores the lack of communication from MSO in this matter, thanx Michael Crane of Biba for his input and thanks the players concerned for dealing with this in a civilised manner.
At this time Bg in London sees very little possibility of working with MSO in the future. One of our reasons for wishing to be involved with MSO is the Olympics 2012 which are to be held in London. We know for a fact that the London Olympics Committee are very keen for other events to surround the 2012 Olympics proper. As such the title "Mind Sports Olympiad" should have a good head start on other organisations despite the MSO having been in decline since it was held in Alexandra Palace in 2000. We were much encouraged when it was announced that MSO 2008 would be held in the Royal Horticultural Halls in Vincent Square - a venue very much like Alexandra Palace. However it then turned out that the event was to be held in the Conference Centre next door to the Halls themselves - not quite the same and an example of, we consider, mis-advertising.

Further we do not see that other mind sports are interested in working with MSO. On the weekend that Bg in London did its bit for MSO there were more backgammon players in-situ than other players of all the other mind sports combined. Those backgammon players were mostly recruited from Biba and Bg in London advertising and attracted by Biba Grand Prix points and a seat at Bg Live in London 2008. We gather the lack of other mind sports players carried on throughout the rest of the MSO week. The MSO website for the event was a disgrace before the event and now 2-3 weeks after the event no results whatsoever at all are posted on the MSO website.

We would therefore like to present MSO with a virtual present:

R.I.P.

 

Mike Main

Report of next event.